home

the Manifesto

current events

CV of the Flag

stories

Making Waves

buy the Flag

Unda Foundation

ANBI

nederlands

vormvlag2b1a1

you can buy the Flag

FLAG OF COMPASSION

stories:

Amsterdam, 6th of April 2016

“Nor yes nor no, we vote compassion”

Since April 1 2015 the Dutch law on the citizen initiative to propose an advisory referendum is in force. An advisory referendum gives the citizen a voice in the political debate between elections. The result of an advisory referendum is not binding. However, in the democratic process it can be an effective measure to enforce the public debate on political issues.
Is the debate on the association agreement with The Ukraine a debate on content? Clearly many media report on the topic and inform us about the content with arguments in favour or against this Treaty. However, will the outcome of the referendum lead to representation of the people?
First, the association agreement has already been signed by the (chosen) representatives of The Netherlands. Second, The Netherlands is only one of the 28 EU-countries, it will be a political difficulty to withdraw. The initiators of the referendum were very much aware of these political difficulties in the EU context and even admitted recently that this initiative is for them not about the content of the issue: the peoples of The Ukraine and The Netherlands, it is about causing tension between The Netherlands and the EU to cause The Netherlands to step outside the EU.
It seems obvious that the governing coalition encourages the voter to vote yes, otherwise the consequences will be political turmoil on both a national and supranational level. It also makes sense that political parties in opposition thankfully use this opportunity to communicate their opinion about the political issue and encourage the voter to vote in accordance of their political position. However, since the Treaty has already been signed it seems to be a bit of a sham.
Simply said, this referendum is a very bad example of referenda in the democratic process, because the question is the wrong question.
In conclusion, The Flag of Compassion offers you a tool to participate in the democratic process supporting the concept of referenda in general and supporting the right to vote in a democratic society. This referendum is not about the content it is about the process. Based on the content of the debate one might even want to be compassionate to both sides. In this specific case voting ‘compassion’ will make the vote content wise invalid, but it will as well make the process of participation visible.

Renee Hartog
 

 

 

 

 

 


 
 

2018 undafoundation

Linda Polman: Port-au-Prince's broad shoulder

Nickel van Duijvenboden: Moving intervention during...

Aimee Zito Lemo: The flag, the weapon

Carin Kampman: Stories full of (com)passion

Maurijn Rouwet: I defend...

Bert Goubitz: The siver mine in Potosi

Emilie Aude Oursel: An introductory notice

Monica Neomagus: Compassion Prize 2012

Yolanda Rommel: Why Compassion?

Christian van der Kaap: How to document a miracle?

Marjolein en Paul: Trouwaarden

Garry Robson: The Flag of Compassion at DaDaFest 2012

Julienne Straatman: Fragment of the speech

Rob van Tulder: Waving a corporate Flag of Compassion

Marlene van der Reiden: Amsterdam Cares

Elly and Jan Hoogteijling: one Flag of Compassion 2008 - 2014

Maaike Bouman: Education of the Heart

5 students Rietveld Academie: Van Abbemuseum goes Compassion

R1

Lars Moratis: The essence of compassion

Renee Hartog: Nor yes nor no, we vote compassion

Masha Popova: The Flag of Compassion Travels to Russia

Iris Blaak: Yes? No? Compassion!

Bertil de Klyn: Compassion and flag

Vita Evangelista: All of us for Every 1

Marjolein and Fabiola: 180 Amsterdammers

Aldo Kempen: A present for my father

Matthias Thibaut: Yet another flag for the Queen

Varamitra: Saying farewell

Jan van Zanen: The city of Martin

Mark Avery: A symbol to rethink our values

Rob and Marij Scholten: Congratulations to the Food Bank

Mark Avery: Independance Day

Suzanne Tesselaar: Stories of Change